What Is a Speculative Bubble? The 5 Stages Explained
What is a speculative bubble? Learn the five stages, see a table of famous bubbles from tulips to NFTs, and where the AI boom sits today: still open.
TL;DR
- A speculative bubble is when prices rise far past what looks sensible, mostly because people expect them to keep rising. Then they fall hard.
- Economists Hyman Minsky and Charles Kindleberger described five stages: displacement, boom, euphoria, profit taking and panic.
- How bad the fall is depends less on what was bought and more on how it was paid for. Borrowed money makes it worse.
- The AI boom is on our list as open and unresolved. As at October 2026, the IMF flagged risks. It did not call an outcome.
- This is education, not financial advice.
If you're curious about crypto and AI, you've heard people say "bubble". A speculative bubble is when the price of something climbs far above what looks reasonable, mostly because buyers expect it to keep climbing. Then the price falls, often fast. There are five stages. History has plenty of examples, from tulips to NFTs. This guide links to each one.
Risk note: bubbles hurt real people. Most NFTs and tokens lose value, and scams thrive in booms. Never put in money you can't afford to lose.
What is a speculative bubble in plain words?
Picture a balloon. Air goes in because people believe it will keep growing. Nobody wants to be the one who stops blowing.
Economists use the word loosely. Markus Brunnermeier and Isabel Schnabel studied 23 episodes over almost 400 years. They say their data can't truly show when a price strays from real value. So by "bubble" they mean a price move that people saw as excessive. It often (but not always) ended in a sharp fall.
That means "bubble" is mostly a label. It's easier to see after the fall than before it.
What are the five stages of a bubble?
The best-known model comes from Hyman Minsky's credit cycle. Charles Kindleberger built on it in his history of financial crises. Forbes sets out the stages like this:
| Stage | What happens | |---|---| | 1. Displacement | Something new draws in investors, such as a technology or very low interest rates | | 2. Boom | Prices rise slowly, then faster, as more people join and the news picks it up | | 3. Euphoria | Caution disappears and prices climb sharply. New reasons appear to justify them | | 4. Profit taking | Informed investors start selling to lock in gains | | 5. Panic | Prices reverse and fall as fast as they rose. People sell at any price |
Authors name the stages a little differently. One peer-reviewed paper uses displacement, boom, overtrading, revulsion and tranquility. The idea is the same: a shock, a rush, a peak, a break, and then calm.
For the five signs that match these stages today, see our guide is AI a bubble.
Which famous bubbles should I know?
Here's a map of the big ones. Each row links to our post where we have one.
| Bubble | When | What people bought | How it ended | Read more | |---|---|---|---|---| | Tulip mania | 1634 to 1637 | Contracts for tulip bulbs | Prices collapsed. Losses were painful but did not spread to the wider economy, per Brunnermeier and Schnabel | The real story | | Mississippi scheme (France) | 1719 to 1720 | Shares in John Law's trading company | Crisis in 1720, closely tied to the South Sea Bubble, per Brunnermeier and Schnabel | No post yet | | South Sea Bubble | 1720 | South Sea Company stock | Collapse in September 1720. Even Newton lost money | South Sea Bubble explained | | Railway Mania | 1840s | Railway shares | A lending boom, then a severe banking crisis and a serious recession, per Brunnermeier and Schnabel | No post yet | | Dot-com | Late 1990s to early 2000s | Internet shares | A mild recession and no major bank failure, per Brunnermeier and Schnabel | Dot-com failures, Webvan | | NFT boom | 2021 to 2022 | NFTs | OpenSea daily volume fell 99% from its 1 May 2022 peak day to 28 August 2022. OpenSea said its monthly volume in ETH fell 62% from May to July | NFT market timeline | | AI boom | Early 2020s to now | AI shares and AI tokens | Open. Unresolved. | Is AI a bubble |
The NFT figures come from Fortune, in August 2022, using DappRadar and Dune data. OpenSea noted that the 99% compared its highest day with one of its lowest.
What makes one bubble worse than another?
Not the asset. The money behind it.
Brunnermeier and Schnabel found that how a bubble is paid for matters more than what it buys. Crises were most severe when lending boomed, traders borrowed heavily and banks joined the buying rush.
Tulip losses stayed in a small group. Railway Mania ended in a banking crisis. The dot-com crash was mostly paid for with share money and ended in a mild recession. That's why economists watch borrowing so closely.
Do economists agree what counts as a bubble?
No. This surprises people.
Even the most famous bubble is argued over. The tulip mania post covers an economist who found most of the episode wasn't obvious madness. It also covers a historian who found few ruined traders. In the South Sea Bubble post, two sets of scholars argue over whether investors acted rationally.
Brunnermeier and Schnabel also note a bias. Records over-represent the bubbles that burst. So history shows us the bad endings more than the quiet ones.
The takeaway: be cautious with anyone who says they know. A bubble call is a guess dressed as a fact.
Where does the AI boom sit?
We list it as open. We don't place it on the stage map. Stage names only fit once you know how things end.
Here's what the IMF said in its October 2026 Global Financial Stability Report. Markets have been resilient, helped by strong earnings and high investment in AI firms. Core AI firms have been profitable so far, which eases pressure on valuations. But weaker or less lasting investment and profits could trigger a correction in AI asset prices. Rising borrowing, concentrated holdings and circular financing could make it worse. A stress test found banks broadly resilient under such a scenario. A significant share would still be vulnerable.
That's a risk warning, not a forecast. We make no call.
How does a bubble affect everyday people?
Mostly through three doors:
- Direct money. People who bought near the top often lose the most.
- Scams. Booms attract fake projects. See NFT scams and how to spot them.
- Jobs and credit. If banks are caught up, a bust can hurt people who owned nothing.
Learn the idea of the greater fool: buying only because you hope someone pays more later. Builders can browse the founder-focused writing on tokens and agents. It shows how token design can reward real use over hype.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a speculative bubble?
It's a run-up in price far above what looks sensible, driven mostly by the hope of further rises. It usually ends in a sharp fall, but not always.
What are the five stages of a bubble?
Displacement, boom, euphoria, profit taking and panic. That's the Minsky and Kindleberger model. Other authors use slightly different names.
What was the biggest bubble in history?
There is no agreed ranking. It depends on what you measure. That could be price rise, share of the economy or damage done.
Do all bubbles crash?
Not always. Brunnermeier and Schnabel say excessive price moves often, but not always, ended in a sharp drop.
Is AI a bubble?
Nobody knows yet. We cover both sides in is AI a bubble.
This is not financial advice. We do not say what to buy, hold or sell, and we make no price predictions.
Next step: pick the bubble that matches your question from the table above. Or start with the real story of tulip mania.
About the Author
James Killick
AI Product, Web3 & Sales Automation Specialist
James Killick runs this site →Digital Product Development
Devwiz is a Sydney-based digital product development agency specialising in launching and scaling SaaS products, web apps and mobile apps. James is a shareholder and advisor, shaping product strategy and PLG approach.
// Related
Keep Reading
Crypto AI Agents: Can They Own and Trade NFTs?
Crypto AI agents explained: how an AI agent can hold a wallet, own NFTs and make trades, what the guardrails are, and the risks you should know first.
What Is Decentralized AI? Who Runs the Computers
What is decentralized AI? A plain-English guide to who runs the computers, how the pieces fit, what's proven so far, and what's still hard. Not advice.