SWNFT
Bubbles and Busts

South Sea Bubble Explained: Newton Lost Money Too

The South Sea Bubble in plain words: what happened in 1720, how Isaac Newton lost money, and what the evidence really says. A clear guide for beginners.

James Killick7 min read

TL;DR

  • The South Sea Bubble was a British stock boom and crash in 1720. The stock stood near 130 at the start of the year. It peaked above 1,000, then fell back to the low hundreds.
  • Isaac Newton did lose money. Scholar Andrew Odlyzko puts the loss at about £10,000 of a fortune of over £30,000. He wasn't ruined.
  • Newton sold early at a profit, then bought back in near the top.
  • The famous "madness of people" quote is not proven.
  • This is history, not financial advice.

The South Sea Bubble was a British stock boom and crash in 1720. The South Sea Company's shares rose to many times their January price. Then they collapsed in September. Even Isaac Newton lost money. Careful research shows about a third of his wealth went, not all of it.

Risk note: bubbles still happen. Most NFTs and tokens lose value, and scams are common. This post is history, not advice.

What was the South Sea Bubble?

It started as a debt deal. In 1711 Britain set up the South Sea Company. Holders of unpaid government bills could swap them for company stock. That stock paid them interest. The company also got a trade monopoly with parts of South America as a sweetener, Andrew Odlyzko explains. Odlyzko is a University of Minnesota researcher who studies financial manias.

In 1720 the company offered to take over most of Britain's national debt. The stock soared. Odlyzko says the boom lasted about half a year. Then came a sharp collapse in September 1720. At the end, the stock made up about 70% of the value of all shares and bonds in Britain.

The Newton Project at Oxford says the price peaked at £1,050, fell to £190 by late summer, and reached £124 by December 1720. Odlyzko puts the price near 130 at the start of the year.

Was it a scam from the start?

No, and this is a common mistake. Odlyzko says people often claim the company was a fraud from the beginning. That's wrong. For years it was a respectable, rather dull firm. People who bought before mid-1719 and held on did well. They made roughly a 50% gain plus dividends.

The trouble came in 1720. Odlyzko describes a "Ponzi" element. Early investors gained at the expense of those lured in during the bubble. A Ponzi scheme pays old investors with money from new ones.

In April 1720 a newspaper article from a "friend" of the company argued something odd. The higher the share price, the better for investors. Odlyzko says it used confusing arithmetic and gave no new reason for higher profits. Critics such as Archibald Hutcheson debunked it, but most people ignored them. The company never gave the public a real business plan.

How did Isaac Newton lose money?

By timing, and by fear of missing out. Here's the order of events, from Odlyzko's study of Newton's records:

  • April 1720: Newton sold his South Sea stock on 19 and 23 April. He made a profit of about £20,000.
  • Spring and early summer: the price stayed flat. Then it began a "vertiginous climb" from the end of May.
  • Mostly mid-June: he bought back in, close to the top. He put almost all of his money into it.
  • September: the price collapsed.

Before the bubble, Newton was worth a little over £30,000. By mid-1721 he was worth about £20,000. That's a loss of about £10,000, Odlyzko says. Newton's income was over £3,000 a year in 1720 money. Odlyzko compares that to about $3 million today. His estate at death in 1727 was about the same as before the bubble. So he wasn't ruined.

The famous story says he lost twice that, about £20,000. Odlyzko calls that plausible. If Newton had simply kept his early profit, he would have ended with over £50,000.

What did Newton say himself?

We do have Newton's own words. In a letter to his friend Nicolas Fatio, Newton wrote that he had "lost very much by the South Sea company," as quoted by Odlyzko. That's a plain admission. Odlyzko notes he was still quite rich.

The line everyone repeats is different. It says he could "calculate the motions of the heavenly bodies, but not the madness of people." Odlyzko says the related story about Newton hating to hear the words "South Sea" can only be traced to about two generations after his death. The Oxford Newton Project page calls the "madness" line a supposed remark. It says the evidence on his exact loss is inconclusive. Odlyzko's later work found more records, so the loss figure is better supported now. The quote is still unproven.

Were smart people fooled too?

Yes. Newton was the president of the Royal Society and Master of the Mint. He was no fool with money. But Odlyzko estimates that 80% to 90% of British investors took part.

One contrast makes the point. Thomas Guy began selling his stock on 22 April 1720, the day after a shareholder meeting. Unlike Newton, he didn't buy back. He used his profit to found Guy's Hospital in London. Odlyzko quotes a London banker who wrote in June 1720 that "when the rest of the world is mad we must imitate them in some measure."

Did everyone act irrationally?

Scholars disagree. In 2005 three researchers published a study in the Economic History Review. They compared prices of South Sea stock and linked subscription receipts and found widening gaps. They concluded that rational explanations weren't enough. They said investors treated the market like a betting game.

In 2007 another historian, Gary Shea, argued their analysis was flawed. He said the contracts had default options built in. He said people of the time understood how they worked.

We won't settle that debate here. Both sides agree on one thing. The price went up and then down hard.

What does the South Sea Bubble teach us?

  • Smart doesn't mean safe. Newton knew money well, and still got caught.
  • Check the plan, not the price. The company never gave a real business plan. If a plan is missing, ask why.
  • Early isn't the same as late. Early buyers and late buyers had very different outcomes.
  • Be careful with famous quotes. The best-known Newton line isn't proven.

The same patterns show up in later booms. Read the real story of tulip mania for an older bubble that's often told wrongly. See the Webvan story for a dot-com example. And see is AI a bubble for how the five usual signs look today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Isaac Newton lose money in the South Sea Bubble?

Yes. Odlyzko's study of his records puts the loss at about £10,000, from a fortune of over £30,000. Newton himself wrote that he had lost very much.

Did Newton say he could not calculate the madness of people?

It's a famous line, but unproven. Even the Oxford Newton Project describes it as a supposed remark.

Was the South Sea Company a fraud?

Not from the start. It began as a debt-swapping firm. Odlyzko says the 1720 boom had a Ponzi-like element. Early investors were paid at the expense of later ones.

How is it like tulip mania?

Both are early bubbles, and both come with myths. But the South Sea Bubble was in company shares, and most British investors took part.

This is not financial advice. We don't say what to buy, hold or sell, and we make no price predictions.

Next step: read the real story of tulip mania to see how another famous bubble story compares with the evidence.

About the Author

James Killick

AI Product, Web3 & Sales Automation Specialist

James Killick runs this site →

Digital Product Development

Devwiz is a Sydney-based digital product development agency specialising in launching and scaling SaaS products, web apps and mobile apps. James is a shareholder and advisor, shaping product strategy and PLG approach.

Visit Devwiz

// Related

Keep Reading