SWNFT
Bubbles and Busts

Tulip Mania: The Real Story, the Myths and NFTs

Tulip mania was real, but the famous tale of ruin is mostly myth. Here is what historians found, why NFTs got compared to it, and what AI agent tokens did.

James Killick7 min read

TL;DR

  • Tulip mania was a real price spike for rare tulip bulbs in the Dutch Republic, from 1634 to early 1637.
  • The famous story of ruined families comes mostly from Charles Mackay's 1841 book. It gave no sources for its prices or dates.
  • Historian Anne Goldgar found very few bankruptcies linked to it, and a small group of people involved.
  • NFTs were compared to tulips in 2021. AI agent tokens fell hard in early 2025. Both comparisons need care.
  • This is education, not financial advice.

Tulip mania was a short craze for rare tulip bulbs in the Dutch Republic in the 1630s. Prices rose fast, then collapsed in early 1637. But historians say the famous tale of national ruin is mostly myth. Few people were wrecked. The economy carried on.

Risk note: NFTs and tokens are high risk. Most lose value, and scams are common.

What was tulip mania?

Tulips came to Western Europe from Turkey in the middle of the 1500s. Rich people loved them. The Dutch grew new kinds, and the rare ones sold for far more than common ones. Economist Peter Garber's 1989 paper explains that the market was for bulbs, not flowers.

Until 1634, only professional growers traded bulbs. Then more people joined in. Garber says formal futures markets grew in 1636. A futures deal is a promise to buy something later at a price set today. Bulbs sit in the ground until summer, so most deals were promises. Garber notes that no bulbs were delivered under the 1636 to 1637 deals before the collapse. It all ended in early February 1637.

What is the myth?

Most modern retellings trace back to Charles Mackay's 1841 book. Garber shows that Mackay gave no sources or dates for his prices. Mackay said one Semper Augustus bulb sold for 5,500 guilders. He told of a sailor who ate a valuable bulb and a visitor who peeled one. He said that after the crash even rare bulbs found no buyers at 10% of old prices, causing long hardship. Garber points out that Mackay offered no evidence for any of it.

The sailor story, Garber says, isn't believable. A Dutch merchant wouldn't leave a bulb worth so much lying about.

The myth lives on because it's useful. Writers have used tulips for generations to warn people about crowds and greed.

What does the evidence show?

Two scholars cut the myth down to size. They came at it from different angles.

Garber looked at price records. He found that most of tulip mania was "not obvious madness." High prices for rare bulbs that fell quickly were a normal pattern in the flower trade. Only the final month looks like a possible bubble. That's when common bulb prices spiked and crashed.

Anne Goldgar went to the archives. A review of her 2007 book says the crisis played out inside a fairly small group. Very few bankruptcies can be tied to tulips alone. The painter Jan van Goyen died bankrupt, but in 1656, nearly twenty years later, after losing money in land deals too. Much of the trade was a chain of promises, and most buyers never paid after prices fell. The most extreme prices come largely from a single pamphlet's account of one February 1637 auction. The Dutch economy wasn't badly hurt.

The real damage, Goldgar argues, was to trust. People broke promises to people they knew.

The two scholars don't fully agree. Garber sees a possible bubble in the last month. Goldgar stresses how small and mild it was. Both reject the legend.

What did tulips cost, and who got hurt?

The honest answer is that we don't know much. In January 1637, a Semper Augustus bulb was asked at 10,000 guilders, the price of a mansion in an Amsterdam district, according to The Art Newspaper. Prices then fell by as much as 90%. Those are asking prices and reported falls. They don't prove crowds lost their homes.

The people with the most to lose were already wealthy tulip fans. Garber notes that the serious, wealthy collectors didn't join the new speculative futures markets. They kept trading rare bulbs afterwards.

Why did people compare NFTs to tulip mania?

In April 2021, The Art Newspaper asked whether NFTs were the "tulipmania" of the 21st century. Beeple's NFT sold at Christie's for $69.3 million on 11 March 2021. A CryptoPunk sold for about $7.5 million, up from about $15,000 three years earlier.

Here's the fair match. Both were a new kind of thing to own. Both had status attached. And in both, buyers' mood set the prices. Here's the weak match: the myth. Tulip mania didn't ruin a nation. So "NFTs are the new tulips" can't be a warning about national ruin.

What did happen to NFTs is in our NFT market timeline. The dot-com bubble is a closer cousin. We compare it in what the dot-com bubble can teach us about NFTs.

What happened with AI agent tokens in 2024 and 2025?

AI agent tokens are crypto coins tied to AI software that acts on its own. The group peaked in early January 2025. The Block reported on 13 January 2025 that its total had reached over $15 billion in early January, then dropped to $12.55 billion. In one week, ai16z fell about 51%, Virtuals about 48% and Swarms over 55%. Bitcoin held near $95,000.

By 6 February 2025, Cointelegraph reported the sector at about $6 billion. That's down roughly 40% from highs above $10 billion. Three big names had lost roughly 75% to 90% since January. The two outlets measure "the sector" differently, so the numbers don't match.

Investor Haseeb Qureshi described many of them to The Block as "chatbots with memecoins attached." We're not naming any of these as something to use. These figures are as at early 2025, and we haven't updated them.

How do tulips and AI agent tokens compare?

| Question | Tulip mania (1634 to 1637) | AI agent tokens (2024 to 2025) | |---|---|---| | What did people hold? | Promises to buy bulbs later | Tokens tied to an AI story | | How fast was the fall? | Collapse in early 1637 | About $15 billion to $12.55 billion in days, then about $6 billion by 6 February 2025 (measures differ) | | Did it spread? | Not seriously, per Goldgar's review | Total crypto market cap was down nearly 16% from January highs by 6 February 2025 | | How good is our data? | Thin and disputed | Public price data, but outlets disagree |

The big lesson sits in the last row. Tulip stories rest on a few old pamphlets. Token figures come from live data. Yet two outlets still gave two different totals.

What should you take from tulip mania?

  • Check the source. The best-known tulip story had none. Ask where a number came from.
  • Know what you hold. A tulip deal was a promise. A token is a claim on a story. Neither is the same as owning something that earns money.
  • Be fair to the past. Call everything "the new tulips" and you repeat a myth.

Want the token side explained? Start with what AI tokens are and AI crypto explained. For the market-wide question, see is AI a bubble. Builders who want the design side can read this guide to token utility versus speculation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was tulip mania real?

Yes. Prices for some bulbs rose sharply in the 1630s and fell in early 1637. What's exaggerated is the size of the damage.

Did people lose their houses over tulips?

Historians haven't found evidence for it. A review of Goldgar's archive work says very few bankruptcies can be linked to tulips alone.

Who wrote the famous tulip story?

Charles Mackay, in 1841. Garber found Mackay gave no sources for his prices or dates.

Are NFTs the new tulips?

Only in a loose way. Both involved status and mood-driven prices. But tulip mania was smaller than the myth says.

This is not financial advice. We don't tell you what to buy, hold or sell, and we make no price predictions.

Next step: read is AI a bubble for the five signs historians use to judge a boom.

About the Author

James Killick

AI Product, Web3 & Sales Automation Specialist

James Killick runs this site →

Digital Product Development

Devwiz is a Sydney-based digital product development agency specialising in launching and scaling SaaS products, web apps and mobile apps. James is a shareholder and advisor, shaping product strategy and PLG approach.

Visit Devwiz

// Related

Keep Reading