SWNFT
NFT Market

The NFT Market Hits Rock Bottom — And That's Why You Should Be Paying Attention

Q3 2023 confirmed the worst NFT quarter since 2021. Average sale price hit $38. But Yuga Labs' co-founder just went on a buying spree. Here's what the data actually means.

James Killick7 min read

The data is in, and Q3 2023 is confirmed: it is the worst quarter for NFT trading since early 2021, before any of this got exciting. Total sales volume came in at $299 million. September was the worst single month since January 2021. Daily unique buyers dropped about 14% to approximately 53,000.

If you've been watching this market, none of that is surprising. It's been sliding all year.

Here's what's more interesting: Yuga Labs co-founder Gordon Goner — real name Wylie Aronow, one of the pseudonymous founders of Bored Ape Yacht Club — went on a very public NFT buying spree on November 7. In a market this quiet, that kind of move gets noticed.

So which is the real signal? The worst quarter in three years, or the co-founder of the most famous NFT project buying aggressively at these prices?

Both, probably. Let me explain why.

The Numbers That Define This Moment

The headline number — $299 million in Q3 sales — doesn't fully convey what's happened. Context does.

At the peak of the bull market, the average NFT sold for $791.84. The current average sale price is $38.17. That's not a typo. The typical NFT transaction today involves about 5 cents for every dollar it involved at the peak. The entire distribution of prices has shifted dramatically downward.

DappRadar's industry report puts September as particularly brutal — the slowest month since January 2021, when the bull run hadn't really started yet. The number of daily unique buyers, which peaked in the hundreds of thousands during the most active periods of 2021–2022, has settled around 53,000. That's a core audience. It's not a mainstream market.

We covered the Q3 setup in our piece on the SEC's second enforcement action and Pudgy Penguins going to Walmart, where the early data was already pointing this direction. The final numbers confirmed the trend.

For context on how far prices have fallen from 2022 specifically, our breakdown of the NFT market crash of 2022 covers the beginning of this decline.

Who Is Actually Growing Market Share

Here's where it gets more complicated than the headline numbers suggest.

Within a declining total market, Ethereum maintained and slightly grew its share of NFT trading activity. More notable: Immutable, the Ethereum Layer 2 blockchain purpose-built for gaming NFTs, grew its share significantly. TensorSwap on Solana emerged as a serious competitor to Magic Eden, and Solana's NFT ecosystem showed resilience that the headline numbers obscure.

Why does this matter? Because market share gains in a down market tend to persist. The platforms and blockchains that attract builders and traders when times are bad tend to be better positioned when times improve. Immutable in particular has been methodically signing gaming partnerships — GameStop, Guild of Guardians, Illuvium, Gods Unchained — throughout the bear market. The user numbers are small, but the infrastructure is being built.

For anyone interested in the Ethereum vs. Solana question specifically, the NFT data from Q3 is actually useful — Solana's lower fees and faster transaction times continue to attract a different segment of the market, particularly for high-frequency, lower-value items.

What Gordon Goner's Buying Spree Means

On November 7, Wylie Aronow (Gordon Goner) began publicly purchasing NFTs from multiple projects — not just Bored Apes or Yuga Labs assets, but broader blue-chip pieces. The purchases were made in a market where the floor prices of these assets are near multi-year lows.

I want to be careful about how I frame this. A co-founder buying at low prices is not a guaranteed signal of anything. Insiders have been wrong before. People with strong conviction in their own projects have held through total collapses. Gordon Goner buying NFTs doesn't mean prices are about to recover.

What it does signal is conviction. Specifically, conviction from someone who has seen this market from the inside — who knows exactly how bad the bear market has been, who understands the regulatory environment, who has visibility into what builders in this space are actually working on — and who is choosing to put real money into NFTs at these price levels.

That's information. It's not a prediction. It's a data point about sentiment among people closest to the asset class.

Contrarian buying at lows is how most of the significant returns in any asset class are generated. Most of those bets also fail. The honest position is: this is worth noting, not worth acting on without your own independent analysis.

The Case for Paying Attention Right Now

Here's my actual view on this moment.

Market bottoms are never obvious in real time. They're only obvious in retrospect. In October 2023, looking at a $299M quarter and $38 average sale prices and 53,000 daily buyers, it is genuinely possible that this is the bottom and things improve from here. It's also genuinely possible that the market continues to decline and this quarter looks like the beginning of a longer deterioration.

But here's what's true regardless of which direction prices go: this is the moment when the signal-to-noise ratio is highest.

In 2021, the hype made it almost impossible to think clearly about what was happening. Everything was going up. Everything felt important. The noise was deafening. The bad projects and the good projects were all rising together, and it was hard to tell them apart.

In late 2023, the noise is gone. What's left are the projects, teams, and platforms that kept building through two years of declining prices and increasing regulatory scrutiny. Those teams are worth paying attention to — not because they're definitely going to succeed, but because survival through a bear market is itself a meaningful signal about quality and conviction.

If you want to understand how to evaluate an NFT project — not based on price momentum, but based on fundamentals — that's exactly the right question to be asking in this market. The basics of what is an NFT and how to buy your first NFT are good starting points if you want to understand the mechanics before thinking about what to look for in a project.

What to Watch Through the End of 2023

A few things worth tracking.

The SEC's enforcement cadence. Two actions in August and September suggests systematic review, not opportunistic enforcement. If there's a third case before year-end, the regulatory pressure narrative becomes even more concrete and the chilling effect on new project launches will continue.

Immutable's gaming partnerships. The infrastructure being built for gaming NFTs on Immutable is potentially the most significant long-term development in the space right now. Real games with real player bases using NFTs for genuine in-game utility would change the market structure fundamentally.

Bitcoin Ordinals. The emergence of Ordinals — a way to inscribe data onto individual satoshis on the Bitcoin blockchain, effectively creating NFTs on Bitcoin — has been one of the more surprising developments of 2023. If that ecosystem continues to develop, it introduces an entirely new demand driver that operates outside the Ethereum ecosystem's current problems.

And frankly, watch how the Pudgy Penguins Walmart rollout performs through the holiday season. Physical toy sales in Q4 are a real test of whether mainstream retail is genuinely interested in NFT-adjacent products or whether the Walmart placement was just a novelty.

The Honest Bottom Line

This market is at or near a multi-year low by most metrics. The question "should I buy NFTs right now" doesn't have a clean answer. The question "should I be paying attention right now" has a clearer one: yes.

Low prices mean low noise. Low noise means you can actually see what's happening. That's useful regardless of whether you end up buying anything.

About the Author

James Killick

AI Product, Web3 & Sales Automation Specialist

James Killick runs this site →

Digital Product Development

Devwiz is a Sydney-based digital product development agency specialising in launching and scaling SaaS products, web apps and mobile apps. James is a shareholder and advisor, shaping product strategy and PLG approach.

Visit Devwiz

// Related

Keep Reading