The Hype Hangover: Why Nakamigos and Checks-VV Couldn't Sustain Their Moments
NFT active traders hit a year-low of 11,187 in April 2023. Nakamigos and Checks-VV spiked and faded. Ethereum held 50%+ of all volume. Here's what's happening.
The NFT market has a pattern that's starting to feel familiar: a new project launches, generates enormous buzz, hits a peak, and then — within days or weeks — the floor price collapses and the conversation moves on.
April 2023 gave us two clear examples of this cycle: Nakamigos and Checks-VV. Both had explosive debuts. Both are now well below their peak prices. And the broader market they launched into is not providing any cushion — active trader counts hit a year-low of approximately 11,187 on April 19th.
This isn't a death knell for NFTs. But it's worth understanding why this keeps happening, and what it means if you're thinking about buying into a new project.
What the April Numbers Actually Show
Let's start with the data.
According to DappRadar, NFT trading volume across all chains in April 2023 reached approximately $514 million. Ethereum dominated, accounting for over 50% of all NFT transaction volume. That Ethereum dominance has been consistent — even as other chains have competed for NFT activity, Ethereum remains where the majority of significant value changes hands.
The active trader figure is the more concerning number. At the peak of the bull market in early 2022, hundreds of thousands of unique wallets were buying and selling NFTs every month. By mid-April 2023, that figure had compressed to around 11,187 active traders on the most active day — a yearly low. The market is not just down in dollar terms. The number of people participating is dramatically smaller.
What this means in practice: the market is increasingly driven by a small number of sophisticated (or at least well-capitalized) participants. Retail buyers who flooded in during 2021-2022 are largely gone.
Whale Consolidation: The Azuki Data Point
This trader consolidation shows up clearly when you look at individual collections.
Azuki, one of the higher-profile anime-style NFT collections, saw a notable shift in April: the number of wallets holding multiple Azuki tokens reportedly roughly doubled during the month. Fewer wallets are holding Azuki, but the ones that are holding them are holding more.
This is called whale consolidation — large holders accumulating while smaller retail holders exit, often at a loss. It's a pattern that appears in traditional markets during bear cycles too. The question is always whether consolidation leads to a genuine recovery or whether the whales are simply buying at a discount before the next exit.
I don't have a confident answer to that question. What I can say is that whale consolidation in a low-volume market doesn't necessarily signal recovery. It often just means the people with the most capital are repositioning.
Nakamigos: The Launch That Burned Bright
Nakamigos launched in April and immediately captured attention. The collection features 20,000 pixel-art characters — simple, deliberately nostalgic designs. They minted free plus gas, which removed the capital risk barrier for early participants. The floor price shot up quickly after launch, and the collection briefly had significant secondary volume.
Then it faded. The floor price dropped substantially from its peak, and trading volume dropped with it.
What happened? A few things.
Free mints attract a specific type of participant: people who are willing to claim something because it costs almost nothing, with the explicit intention of selling quickly if the price moves. When those participants flip on the way up, the supply overhang hits the market simultaneously, and buyers who came in at the peak are underwater. The community that remains is whoever didn't sell — and in a free mint, that's often a smaller committed core surrounded by a much larger group of speculators.
Nakamigos also launched without clear utility or a detailed roadmap. The appeal was the art style and the free entry point. That's a legitimate aesthetic proposition, but it doesn't give holders a reason to hold during a price decline.
Checks-VV: When Concept Isn't Enough to Sustain a Market
Checks-VV is a more interesting case, because it started as a genuinely conceptual project.
Jack Butcher, a designer and creative director, launched Checks as an art project built around a grid of colored checkmarks. The mechanics were unusual: you could "burn" tokens to reduce the number of checks, with a single-check token being the rarest tier. It had a conceptual framework that attracted serious art collectors and the crypto-native art community.
Checks-VV — the "visual variant" — extended that premise. It had a strong launch and attracted real secondary market activity.
But the broader market conditions weren't supportive, and once the initial excitement passed, volume and prices declined. The conceptual depth that made Checks interesting to the art community isn't the kind of thing that drives sustained speculative demand in a bear market. When buyers are scarce, even well-constructed projects struggle to hold value.
The Checks story isn't over — it still has a genuine collector community. But April showed that concept and community don't automatically translate to price stability when the broader market is contracting.
Open Editions: A Different Model Emerges
One of the more interesting structural shifts happening in April is the rise of open editions.
Traditional NFT collections have fixed supply — 10,000 Bored Apes, 8,888 Moonbirds, etc. The scarcity is artificial but it's fixed. Open editions work differently: there's a mint window (say, 24 or 48 hours), and anyone who wants to participate can. There's no cap on supply. After the window closes, the supply is fixed at whatever was minted.
The economics are different. With an open edition, you can't generate FOMO around supply — everyone who wanted one could get one. The value has to come from the artist's reputation, the cultural meaning of the moment, or the community that forms around the collection.
Artists like Jack Butcher, Daniel Arsham, and others have used open editions effectively. They work best when the artist already has a following that values their work directly, rather than as a speculative vehicle.
For new collectors, open editions are worth understanding because they change the risk profile. You're paying for access and participation, not for artificial scarcity. That might actually be a more honest model.
Starbucks Drops Its Second Collection
On the corporate side, Starbucks continued rolling out Odyssey content in April with the First Store Collection — a second set of stamps for Odyssey members, themed around Starbucks' original Seattle store location.
The First Store Collection followed a similar structure to the Siren Collection sellout in March — limited stamp supply, tied to the Odyssey loyalty program, no crypto wallet required for participants. Starbucks is building this program methodically, one drop at a time.
It's a contrast worth noting: while the speculative NFT market is experiencing declining participation, Starbucks' NFT-powered loyalty program is expanding its content library and (presumably) its user base. The two narratives are running in parallel without much intersection.
What the Hype Hangover Actually Teaches You
If you've watched a few of these cycles now — and April 2023 is probably your third or fourth if you've been paying attention since 2021 — a pattern becomes visible.
The hype spike happens when a project captures attention in the right places at the right time. The Discord blows up, Twitter goes into a frenzy, the floor price doubles in a day. Then the people who got in early start taking profits. The people who got in at the top are holding bags. The discourse moves on to the next project.
This doesn't mean all NFT launches are scams or worthless. It means that the secondary market price of a new collection is mostly a measure of current narrative momentum, not fundamental value. In a market with 11,000 active traders, narrative momentum is fleeting.
The projects that hold value over time tend to have a few things in common: a community that holds because they genuinely want to, a creator or team that keeps building, and some form of utility or identity that doesn't depend purely on price going up. That's a shorter list than the full universe of NFT projects.
For context on how we got here — from the FTX collapse through the Blur airdrop to today — see our February post on the marketplace wars and our January post on what the market looked like when it first started recovering.
Where Things Stand in Late April
The honest summary: the NFT market in April 2023 is a smaller, more consolidated market than it was twelve months ago. Active participation is at yearly lows. Most of the speculative retail buyers are gone. The collections that have survived are held by a shrinking group of committed holders and whales.
That's not inherently a bad thing — smaller markets can be healthier markets. The question is what builds on top of this base. The Starbucks model suggests one direction. The open editions trend suggests another. Bitcoin Ordinals are slowly developing tooling and community.
The hype hangover is real. But hangovers end.
About the Author
James Killick
AI Product, Web3 & Sales Automation Specialist
James Killick runs this site →Digital Product Development
Devwiz is a Sydney-based digital product development agency specialising in launching and scaling SaaS products, web apps and mobile apps. James is a shareholder and advisor, shaping product strategy and PLG approach.
// Related
Keep Reading
Crypto AI Agents: Can They Own and Trade NFTs?
Crypto AI agents explained: how an AI agent can hold a wallet, own NFTs and make trades, what the guardrails are, and the risks you should know first.
What Is a Speculative Bubble? The 5 Stages Explained
What is a speculative bubble? Learn the five stages, see a table of famous bubbles from tulips to NFTs, and where the AI boom sits today: still open.