SWNFT
NFT Market

Where Are NFTs Now? A Mid-2025 Market Assessment

A mid-2025 check-in on the NFT market: more buyers, lower prices, AI-generated art rising, and brands learning from Starbucks Odyssey. Here's the honest picture.

James Killick7 min read

Every August I find myself doing the same thing: pulling back from the day-to-day noise and trying to see what's actually changed.

The 2021 NFT peak feels like a different era now. The $69 million Beeple sale, the endless profile picture launches, the gas wars that made buying an NFT a competitive sport. That market was driven by a very specific set of conditions — ultra-low interest rates, pandemic-era boredom, and a genuine sense that something transformative was happening, even if nobody could quite articulate what.

Those conditions are gone. What replaced them is a market that is structurally different in ways that are both encouraging and sobering depending on what you were hoping to see.

More Buyers, Lower Average Prices

Here's the headline number that most commentary gets wrong: total NFT buyers are up significantly year-on-year, while dollar volumes are substantially lower than the 2021 peak.

That combination sounds contradictory. More buyers spending less total money. But it's actually coherent once you understand what's happening: the average price of an NFT has dropped dramatically, which means the market has democratised. Fewer whale-driven, six-figure trades. More regular people buying lower-priced items.

This is a healthier market structure than 2021. A market where a small number of very wealthy participants drive most of the volume is fragile — when those participants exit, volume collapses. A market with a broader base of buyers at lower price points is more durable.

The caveat: lower average prices mean lower average returns for sellers. If you're sitting on NFTs from 2021 and hoping to recoup your investment, this market structure is not encouraging news.

For new buyers, though, the lower price environment means you can participate in NFT collecting without needing significant capital. That was never true in 2021. Whether that's worth doing still depends on what you're buying and why — this post on whether NFTs are a good investment covers the framework for thinking about it.

AI-Generated NFT Art Is Now a Significant Category

Two years ago, AI-generated NFT art was a curiosity and, frankly, a source of controversy. Artists were understandably concerned about AI tools trained on their work without consent.

Those concerns haven't disappeared, but the category has grown regardless. AI-generated NFT art now represents a meaningful and growing subset of the broader NFT art market. Collections that blend human curation with AI generation have found audiences. Some AI artists have built significant followings on Foundation and other platforms.

The royalty and provenance questions are complicated. When an AI generates an image, who owns it? The person who prompted it? The company whose model generated it? These questions are still being worked out, both legally and culturally. This post on NFT copyright and ownership covers the broader ownership question, though the AI layer adds new complexity that the law hasn't fully caught up to.

What I'd say to collectors: AI-generated NFT art can be genuinely interesting and worth collecting on aesthetic merit. Just be clear with yourself about what you're buying. You're buying an image and a token. The story of who (or what) made it is part of the value proposition, so understand that story before you pay for it.

Platforms like Art Blocks, which pioneered generative NFT art using on-chain algorithms, have a different model than prompt-based AI art — the code that generates the work is itself the art. That distinction matters to many collectors and is worth understanding if you're entering the art NFT space.

Brand NFT Programmes: Learning from Starbucks

Starbucks Odyssey launched in December 2022 with genuine ambition. It was one of the most thoughtful brand NFT programmes of the era — a loyalty programme that used NFTs to give real-world benefits to real Starbucks customers, designed to make blockchain invisible to the user.

It shut down in March 2024.

This post reviewed the Starbucks Odyssey programme in detail while it was running. The lessons from its closure have been instructive for every brand that came after.

What went wrong was not the concept — it was the execution economics. Running an NFT loyalty programme at Starbucks' scale required enormous ongoing investment in infrastructure, customer support, and community management. The revenue case was hard to prove. And the web3-native audience that embraced it was not the same audience that drives Starbucks' core business.

Brands in 2025 are taking narrower approaches. Smaller programmes, more targeted audiences, clearer value exchange. Nike's digital collectible division, which operates through its RTFKT acquisition, has continued to produce limited-edition NFT drops with genuine physical redemption options. Nike learned that the web3 audience wants things that are exclusive and functional, not just digital.

The brands that are making it work have stopped trying to convert their existing customer base to crypto and started treating NFTs as a separate channel for a separate audience. That's a more honest approach.

Pudgy Penguins: The Durable Consumer Brand

Of all the collections that launched in the 2021-2022 era, Pudgy Penguins has made the strongest case for long-term survival as a consumer brand rather than just a speculative NFT collection.

The physical toy line launched in 2023 and sold through Walmart. The PENGU token launched on Solana in late 2024 and bridged the collection's community into the DeFi space. The brand has maintained cultural relevance without relying on floor price performance to sustain community interest.

That's a meaningful achievement. Most PFP collections tried to become brands and discovered that brand-building is hard work that doesn't happen just because you have a Discord server and a celebrity holder. Pudgy Penguins did the work. The physical merchandise, the licensing deals, the token launch — these were deliberate steps toward building something that exists independently of the NFT market cycle.

I covered the collection's comeback in this post on Pudgy Penguins when it was just starting to show signs of resilience. What's happened since then exceeded what seemed likely at the time.

Looking Ahead: The 2028 Halving Cycle

Bitcoin's next halving is projected for early 2028. Historically — and with the caveat that three data points is not a robust sample — Bitcoin halvings have been followed by broader crypto bull markets. The 2024 halving was followed by a significant Bitcoin price run, which spilled over into the broader NFT market to a modest degree.

If the pattern holds, 2026 and 2027 might be years of gradual accumulation before a more significant market expansion around 2028. That's speculative. It's based on a pattern that may not repeat.

What I'd say: if you're interested in NFTs and thinking long-term, the current market — with lower prices and less competition for assets — is a more rational time to explore the space than a peak. That doesn't make it a risk-free time. It just means you're not competing against maximum FOMO.

The Block's research team has published useful data on NFT market structure this year if you want numbers to anchor your thinking rather than narratives.

The Honest Assessment

NFTs in August 2025 are neither dead nor thriving. They occupy a middle ground that is difficult to characterise simply.

The speculative bubble is definitively over. The technology is more capable than it was three years ago. The user base is broader and, in some ways, more genuine — people buying NFTs for use rather than purely for resale.

The things that were always true are still true: most NFTs will decline in value, most projects will not build the community they promised, and buying anything primarily because you expect to sell it for more later is speculation, not investing.

The things that have changed: the infrastructure is better, the use cases are clearer, the scam density has declined somewhat as the quick-money crowd moved on to other markets.

If you're new to NFTs and wondering whether now is a reasonable time to learn about them, the answer is yes — as long as you're clear about what you're doing and why. That's always been the answer, honestly. It's just easier to hear it now that the noise has died down.

About the Author

James Killick

AI Product, Web3 & Sales Automation Specialist

James Killick runs this site →

Digital Product Development

Devwiz is a Sydney-based digital product development agency specialising in launching and scaling SaaS products, web apps and mobile apps. James is a shareholder and advisor, shaping product strategy and PLG approach.

Visit Devwiz

// Related

Keep Reading