The Great Recovery Begins: NFT Monthly Volumes Cross $1 Billion Again
NFT monthly sales crossed $1 billion in November 2023 for the first time in months. Here's what drove the recovery and what it actually means.
The NFT market just crossed $1 billion in monthly sales volume for the first time in months. That's the headline. Before you start celebrating or dismissing it, let's actually look at what happened and what it means.
For context: if you've been watching NFT floor prices quietly bleed out through most of 2023, this is a notable shift. Not a guaranteed turning point — notable. There's a difference.
What the Numbers Actually Show
November 2023 NFT sales volume crossed the $1 billion mark across all major chains and marketplaces. That includes Ethereum, Solana, Bitcoin Ordinals, and the smaller chains filling in around the edges.
To put that in perspective: we've been well below that threshold for most of the year. The NFT market peaked somewhere around $17 billion in monthly volume during the January 2022 mania. Then it fell. Hard. If you want the full story of how that unfolded, I covered it in the Q1 2023 NFT market review — the short version is that most of 2023 was a long, grinding contraction.
So $1 billion feels like a lot after months of sub-$500 million months. It's still nowhere near the peak. But direction matters as much as absolute numbers, and the direction changed.
Who Led the Charge
This wasn't a uniform rising tide. Some collections specifically drove the volume spike.
Pudgy Penguins
Pudgy Penguins had a standout November. The collection's floor price climbed significantly, and the project has been building credibility through its physical toy expansion — something I'll cover in more detail when their Walmart story fully develops. For now, the key point is that Pudgy Penguins is one of the few PFP collections that has articulated a real-world growth strategy and then executed on it. The market is noticing.
Mad Lads
Mad Lads is a Solana-native collection that launched in April 2023, and it's been one of the cleaner success stories of the bear market. November saw meaningful floor price increases here too. Mad Lads benefits from the broader Solana ecosystem momentum — Solana's relative speed and low transaction costs have made it more attractive for NFT trading activity than it was during the Ethereum-dominated peak.
Milady Maker
Milady is a strange one. The collection has a dedicated and vocal community, an aesthetic that's recognizable, and a floor price that moves with unusual energy. November included Milady in the mix of collections showing meaningful appreciation. Whether you understand the cultural appeal of Milady or not, the market data is straightforward.
The Blue Chips Moved Too
CryptoPunks, Azuki, and Bored Ape Yacht Club all saw floor price increases in November. The blue-chip collections tend to move more slowly than mid-tier collections — they're less liquid, and the buyers at those price points are more deliberate. When blue chips move meaningfully alongside mid-tier collections, it usually signals something broader than a single-collection story.
The Narrative Shift
Here's something worth paying attention to: the commentary in NFT spaces changed noticeably in November.
For most of 2023, the dominant narrative was "NFTs are dead." That phrase showed up constantly in mainstream coverage, in crypto Twitter arguments, in podcast takes. And look, that narrative wasn't entirely wrong — trading volumes were down, many collections had lost 90% or more of their peak value, and the celebrity-driven hype from 2021 had completely evaporated.
But "dead" and "found a floor" are different things. By November, the conversation was shifting toward the latter. Collections that survived the bear market without collapsing their communities or abandoning their roadmaps were getting credit for it. The market started to distinguish between projects that had actual communities behind them and projects that were pure speculation vehicles.
If you want a framework for telling the difference, the how to evaluate an NFT project guide is worth reading — the criteria that matter in a recovery look different from the criteria that mattered in a bull market.
Bitcoin Ordinals: The Wild Card
You can't talk about the November recovery without talking about Bitcoin Ordinals. By early November, the Ordinals protocol had seen over 56 million inscriptions on the Bitcoin blockchain. That number is significant.
Ordinals launched in January 2023 and introduced a way to inscribe data — images, text, anything really — directly onto individual satoshis on the Bitcoin blockchain. It's a different paradigm than Ethereum NFTs, and it attracted a different crowd. Bitcoin maximalists who had previously dismissed NFTs entirely found themselves engaging with Ordinals because the asset lives natively on Bitcoin.
The Ordinals ecosystem was contributing meaningfully to overall NFT market volume numbers by November. It also added a new narrative layer: NFTs weren't just an Ethereum story anymore. Bitcoin was in it.
The Bitcoin ETF Anticipation Trade
Something bigger was happening in the background that you need to understand to fully explain November 2023.
The SEC had been reviewing applications for spot Bitcoin ETFs throughout the year. By November, the expectation that approval was coming — and soon — was driving crypto sentiment broadly. Bitcoin's price had been climbing since early 2023 in anticipation of this moment.
When Bitcoin's price rises, crypto sentiment improves across the board. NFT markets don't operate in isolation from the broader crypto environment. Improved sentiment means more wallets are active, more capital is available to deploy, and collectors who had been sitting on the sidelines start paying attention again.
The ETF anticipation trade was a rising tide that lifted a lot of boats in November. That context matters when you're evaluating whether the recovery reflects underlying NFT market strength or external macro conditions.
Honestly, it was probably both.
What Didn't Change
I want to be honest about what the $1 billion milestone doesn't tell you.
It doesn't tell you that the worst collections came back. The projects that collapsed their communities, abandoned their roadmaps, or turned out to be outright cash grabs are still worthless. The market isn't indiscriminate about this anymore. The 2021 bull market lifted genuinely terrible projects to absurd prices. The recovery is more selective.
It doesn't tell you that Blur's dominance over OpenSea changed. Blur was still capturing the majority of Ethereum NFT trading volume through November. The marketplace landscape is different from 2021, and that affects how volume numbers translate to creator economics.
And it doesn't guarantee continuation. One strong month after a long contraction is a data point. It's not a trend yet.
My Take
I've been skeptical of recovery calls throughout 2023 because the macro environment didn't support them. Most of the "recovery" signals earlier in the year turned out to be dead-cat bounces.
November feels different for a few reasons. The collections leading the charge have genuine community support and real-world development stories. The Bitcoin Ordinals ecosystem adds a new dimension to overall market activity that wasn't present before. And the macro backdrop — Bitcoin ETF expectations, Bitcoin price strength — provides real tailwind rather than pure speculation.
This might be the beginning of something. Or it might be another head fake. I'm not going to pretend I know which one. What I'll say is that this is the first month in a while where I looked at the data and thought "this is worth paying attention to" rather than "this is wishful thinking."
Watch the December numbers. If volume holds above $1 billion and the blue-chip floors hold, that's a trend. One month is still just one month.
Further Reading
- DappRadar NFT Market Reports — good source for ongoing volume data
- The Block Research — solid on-chain analysis and market data
- CoinDesk NFT Coverage — news and analysis on major developments
About the Author
James Killick
AI Product, Web3 & Sales Automation Specialist
James Killick runs this site →Digital Product Development
Devwiz is a Sydney-based digital product development agency specialising in launching and scaling SaaS products, web apps and mobile apps. James is a shareholder and advisor, shaping product strategy and PLG approach.
// Related
Keep Reading
Greater Fool Theory Explained: NFTs to AI Memecoins
The greater fool theory in plain English: why people buy overpriced things, how NFT floor prices showed it, and how it looks in AI agent memecoins.
AI Tokenization Explained: Where AI Meets Real-World Assets
AI tokenization explained: the two meanings, how AI helps check, run and trade tokenised real-world assets, and the risks to know first.